The Transition to Three Lunch Periods: Advantageous or Adverse?
May 20, 2022
At MICDS Upper School, lunch periods are divided into three categories: first, split, and third lunch. However, opinions regarding the efficacy of this scheduling are divided.
When asked about how third lunch impacts her classroom experience, senior Aishani Chakraborty shares, “I feel like I’m concentrating more on trying to suppress my grumbling stomach or watching the clock rather than what we are actually learning.”
Unfortunately, these feelings can interfere with students’ concentration and in-class learning. As Olivia Rickers, also a senior at MICDS, points out, “When I am hungry no work will get done whatsoever. I never retain anything from classes that I have during third lunch days.”
However, teachers are well informed of these difficulties. When asked about the teachers’ perspective on student concentration during the third lunch, AP Psychology teacher Diane Gioia shares, “We can see the fatigue. Late lunches for some students might be really challenging, especially those who had back to back classes or tests before.”
These arguments are often made in support of reversing the recent transition to three lunch periods. At its core, however, this transition was implemented to facilitate the transition from trimesters to semesters. Specifically, administrators aimed to decrease the heavy cafeteria congestion and extensive lines for hot-lunch and the panini station by distributing the student flow into three periods, as opposed to two.
As Dean Gioia points out, the lunchroom “can’t handle the traffic of 600 students in two lunches” with its current configuration.
While some high schools operate on two lunch schedules, they structure them so students sit by advisory and self-serve themselves from platters on their tables. Conversely, MICDS strives to offer students more choice in choosing their meals, providing options like hot lunch, the salad and panini stations, ice-cream machine, and more.
In return, MICDS staggers the lunch periods to alleviate pressure on the staff and avoid long student lines. While third lunch periods currently have complex impacts on the student body, the Upper School community can look forward to increased lunchroom capacity in the long-term future, as administrators are considering renovations to the cafeteria.